+86 755 8277 4696
English
Original Part

Switch 600V 100A

quote
Alternative Part

Switch 600V 100A

quote

Substitution Feasibility Conclusion

It cannot be definitively concluded that the VKA3100N can safely replace the 19217-11 without obtaining and verifying the complete technical specifications from both parties. Relying solely on identical basic voltage and current parameters poses a substantive substitution risk.

Comparison Points

1. Brand and Technology Platform Variance: The components are manufactured by American Electrical and Altech, respectively, each with distinct design standards, material processes, and validation procedures. Significant differences may exist in internal construction, arc quenching capability, contact resistance, thermal rise characteristics, and long-term reliability. These factors directly impact performance and service life under full load, frequent operation, or harsh environmental conditions. 2. Mechanical and Electrical Endurance: The rated mechanical life (no-load) and electrical life (under rated load) for the two models are almost certainly different. These are core parameters for evaluating switch durability and replacement intervals. If the VKA3100N has a shorter lifespan, substitution would lead to increased maintenance frequency. 3. Safety Certifications and Standards Compliance: The specific safety certifications held by each model (e.g., UL, CE, specific clauses of IEC standards) are not explicitly listed. If the original design relies on particular certifications of the 19217-11 (such as UL 508 for Industrial Control Equipment), and the substitute model lacks corresponding certifications, it could invalidate the certification of the entire equipment system. This introduces compliance and market access risks. 4. Mounting and Connection Method: Differences may exist in dimensions, mounting hole patterns, and terminal types (e.g., bolt specifications, torque requirements). This involves physical compatibility issues. A direct replacement may result in inability to mount or unreliable connections, potentially requiring modifications to the panel or wiring terminals. A direct substitution may lead to degraded equipment performance, increased safety hazards, compliance failures, or higher installation costs. Prior to implementing any replacement, a thorough comparison of both complete datasheets is mandatory, with focused verification of the above-listed differences, followed by necessary testing.
Analysis ID: D187-B66B000
Based on part parameters and for reference only. Not to be used for procurement or production.
SkyChip © 2026, Email: sales@skychip.com