+86 755 8277 4696
English
Original Part

Bipolar (BJT) Transistor NPN 50 V 3 A 100MHz 1.6 W Surface Mount SOT-89

quote
Alternative Part

Bipolar (BJT) Transistor NPN 60 V 3 A 200MHz 2 W Surface Mount MPT3

quote

Substitution Feasibility Conclusion

In most demanding applications, direct substitution is not recommended. A thorough evaluation based on the specific critical requirements of the circuit is necessary.

Comparison Points

1. Saturation Voltage (Vce(sat)): At comparable operating currents, the PBSS4350X exhibits a significantly lower saturation voltage (typically around 200mV level vs. the higher value for the 2SC5824). In switching or linear applications, this translates to lower conduction losses, reduced heat generation, and higher efficiency for the PBSS4350X. 2. DC Current Gain (hFE): The PBSS4350X maintains a higher minimum gain (300) even at a larger collector current (1A), whereas the 2SC5824T100R has a lower minimum gain (180) at a smaller current (100mA). When driving the same load current, the PBSS4350X requires less base drive current, easing the demands on the drive circuit and simplifying control. 3. Frequency Response (fT): The transition frequency (200MHz) of the 2SC5824T100R is twice that of the PBSS4350X (100MHz). This gives the former a distinct performance advantage in high-frequency amplification or high-speed switching applications, resulting in lower signal distortion. 4. Quality & Reliability Qualification: The PBSS4350X is explicitly marked as compliant with the AEC-Q100 automotive-grade standard. It has undergone more rigorous reliability testing, making it suitable for harsh-environment and long-lifetime applications such as automotive electronics. The 2SC5824T100R does not indicate this certification. Evaluation Recommendation: For circuits sensitive to conduction loss, drive efficiency, and reliability grade, the PBSS4350X should be the preferred choice. If the circuit operates in the high-frequency domain and has relaxed requirements for saturation voltage, the 2SC5824T100R may be considered.
Analysis ID: 1613-F7AA000
Based on part parameters and for reference only. Not to be used for procurement or production.
SkyChip © 2026, Email: sales@skychip.com