Original Part
Alternative Part
Optoisolator Transistor Output 5300Vrms 1 Channel 4-SMD
1. SFH615A-3X017 Substitution Conclusion
Overall, the SFH615A-3X017 can serve as a limited substitute for the HCPL-817-36BE, provided key parametric differences are noted. The primary deviations are: a narrower Current Transfer Ratio (CTR) range (100%-200% @ 10mA, compared to 130%-260% @ 5mA for the original part), which may result in weaker output drive capability under identical input conditions and necessitates verification of load matching in the actual circuit; a slightly higher forward voltage (1.35V vs. 1.2V), potentially leading to a marginal increase in input-side power dissipation; and a significantly higher Vce(sat) (400mV vs. 200mV), which increases conduction losses in the output stage and reduces voltage margin under low-voltage loads. However, its isolation voltage (5300Vrms) and switching speed are slightly superior. Substitution can be considered for applications with relaxed requirements on CTR margin and saturation voltage.
2. ISP817SMT&R Substitution Conclusion
The ISP817SMT&R is a viable substitute for the HCPL-817-36BE in terms of basic isolation and voltage ratings. The primary concern is the risk of inconsistency due to its extremely wide Current Transfer Ratio (CTR) range (50%-600% @ 5mA). The significant gain variation between devices may degrade signal transmission stability in volume production, requiring wider threshold tolerances in the design or the addition of a screening process. Other parameters, such as forward voltage (1.2V), Vce(sat) (200mV), and output voltage (80V), are comparable or superior to the original part. Substitution is feasible if the application can tolerate high CTR dispersion, for example, through circuit adjustments for compensation.
Analysis ID: 0C79-1055000
Based on part parameters and for reference only. Not to be used for procurement or production.
SkyChip © 2026, Email: sales@skychip.com