Original Part
Alternative Part
1. ISL83072EIBZA Substitution Conclusion
Direct substitution is not recommended. It may only be considered for specific applications where performance requirements are significantly downgraded. The key differences are its data rate of only 250kbps (far lower than the original 1Mbps) and a receiver hysteresis of merely 15mV (compared to the original 35mV). This model's communication bandwidth is severely inadequate to meet the speed requirements of the original design. Furthermore, its weaker noise immunity makes it more susceptible to bit errors from signal jitter in noisy industrial environments, leading to reduced system reliability.
2. ADM3078EARZ Substitution Conclusion
Direct substitution is feasible in terms of electrical interface and basic functionality. However, careful attention must be paid to the impact of its superior performance parameters on the system design. The differences lie in its data rate of up to 16Mbps (significantly higher than the original 1Mbps) and a receiver hysteresis as high as 100mV (exceeding the original 35mV). While this model offers ample communication headroom, it may also introduce more significant signal integrity and electromagnetic compatibility challenges. The existing PCB layout must be evaluated for its ability to support such high speeds. The extremely high hysteresis provides robust noise immunity, but at the cost of reduced receiver sensitivity to minor signal variations. In long-distance communication with severe signal attenuation, the effective noise margin may actually be lower.
Analysis ID: 43F9-C61D000
Based on part parameters and for reference only. Not to be used for procurement or production.
SkyChip © 2026, Email: sales@skychip.com