Original Part
Asynchronous FIFO 512 x 9 Uni-Directional 33.3MHz 20ns 28-PDIP

Alternative Part
Asynchronous FIFO 4.5K (512 x 9) Uni-Directional 50MHz 12ns 28-PDIP

Substitution Feasibility Conclusion
Given full functional and pin compatibility, the 7201LA12TPG can directly replace the 7201LA20TP, but cost-effectiveness must be evaluated. While the substitution will significantly increase system timing margin, it may constitute over‑specification if the original design does not fully utilize the higher performance.
Comparison Points
1. Performance and Speed Grade
- Difference: The 7201LA20TP has an access time of 20 ns and a maximum data rate of 33.3 MHz; the 7201LA12TPG offers 12 ns and 50 MHz.
- This is not merely a numerical difference but reflects distinct speed grades. The 12TPG provides greater timing margin and bandwidth capability, making it suitable for higher‑speed or more timing‑critical systems. After substitution, the original system’s timing margin will become considerably more relaxed, substantially improving timing‑related stability.
2. Cost and Value Positioning
- Difference: The 7201LA12TPG (USD 12.53) is priced about 10.6 times higher than the 7201LA20TP (USD 1.18).
- The large price gap primarily reflects performance premium and potential market scarcity (e.g., discontinuation, supply status). This results in a low cost‑benefit ratio for substitution. Unless the original system must be upgraded due to performance bottlenecks, or the 20TP is obsolete with no other lower‑cost alternatives, paying a tenfold premium for unused performance is generally uneconomical.
Summary Recommendation:
If the original system operates near or at the 33.3 MHz limit, or if performance uplift is required, the substitution is feasible and beneficial. If the system runs at significantly lower frequencies (e.g., well below 33 MHz), the priority should be to source a same‑speed‑grade alternative (e.g., 20 ns) to control cost. Direct use of the 12TPG is technically safe but may not be economically justified.
Analysis ID: 281F-DD2E000
Based on part parameters and for reference only. Not to be used for procurement or production.
SkyChip © 2026, Email: sales@skychip.com
