+86 755 8277 4696
English
Original Part

Bipolar (BJT) Transistor NPN 80 V 1 A 100MHz 1.3 W Surface Mount SOT-223

quote
Alternative Part

Bipolar (BJT) Transistor NPN 80 V 1 A 1.6 W Surface Mount SOT-223

quote

Substitution Feasibility Conclusion

In most general-purpose applications, the BCP56-16 can serve as a drop-in replacement for the BCP56-16-AQ. However, limitations in high-frequency operation and low-temperature startup scenarios must be considered. For cost-sensitive designs or applications with demanding high-frequency performance, further evaluation is recommended.

Comparison Points

1. Maximum Power Dissipation (1.6 W vs. 1.3 W): The BCP56-16 offers a higher power margin. This suggests it may feature a lower thermal resistance or improved heatsinking within the same package, enabling operation at higher ambient temperatures or under sustained load conditions. 2. Transition Frequency (100MHz vs. Unspecified): The BCP56-16-AQ specifies an fT of 100MHz, making it suitable for high-frequency switching or amplification circuits. The absence of this specification for the BCP56-16 indicates its high-frequency performance may not be optimized or characterized, posing a potential risk in RF-sensitive applications. 3. Operating Temperature Range (-55°C~150°C vs. Only 150°C Max Specified): The BCP56-16-AQ explicitly supports low-temperature startup down to -55°C, qualifying it for wide-temperature environments such as industrial or automotive cold-crank conditions. The BCP56-16 lacks a specified minimum temperature, implying guaranteed performance only above room temperature, with undefined characteristics at low temperatures. 4. Manufacturer & Pricing (STMicroelectronics vs. Diotec): The ST version carries a significantly higher price, typically reflecting tighter quality control, more comprehensive reliability data, and greater supply chain stability. The Diotec variant is likely a cost-optimized part, suitable for reducing BOM cost in non-critical applications.
Analysis ID: BF5B-0BFC000
Based on part parameters and for reference only. Not to be used for procurement or production.
SkyChip © 2026, Email: sales@skychip.com