Original Part
Alternative Part
1. AD8058ARZ-REEL7 Substitution Conclusion
From an architecture and package perspective, the AD8058, as a voltage-feedback amplifier, is a direct architectural substitute for the MAX412 and offers a wider supply range (3V to 12V). However, there are significant differences in its core parameters. The AD8058's bandwidth (325 MHz) and slew rate (1150 V/µs) far exceed those of the original part (28 MHz, 4.5 V/µs), making it an ultra-high-speed op-amp. This performance comes at the cost of a significantly worse input offset voltage (1 mV vs. 120 µV) and a quiescent current (14 mA) several times higher. This part can only be considered as a substitute in applications requiring extremely high speed where DC precision and power consumption are not critical. For the general-purpose, medium-speed, medium-to-high-precision applications originally served by the MAX412, direct substitution is generally not viable due to its poor DC precision and high power consumption, potentially leading to degraded accuracy, excessive power draw, or stability issues.
2. AD8072JRZ-REEL7 Substitution Conclusion
This part is a current-feedback amplifier, whose operating principle is fundamentally different from that of the original MAX412 (a voltage-feedback amplifier). Its bandwidth (100 MHz) and slew rate (500 V/µs) are also significantly higher than the original part, making it designed for high-speed signal processing such as in video applications. Due to its architecture, it cannot directly substitute into typical voltage-feedback application circuits. This is especially true in circuits requiring high closed-loop gain, integrators, or low-impedance feedback networks, where it may cause malfunction or even oscillation. Although its supply range and package are compatible, substitution should only be considered if the original circuit was specifically designed for a current-feedback amplifier (e.g., high-speed buffers, video drivers). Direct substitution in general-purpose op-amp circuits is essentially not feasible.
Analysis ID: 235F-8E68000
Based on part parameters and for reference only. Not to be used for procurement or production.
SkyChip © 2026, Email: sales@skychip.com



