(HKG) +86 755 8277 4696
WhatsAppWhatsApp
English
SkyChip
0
Original Part

N-Channel 650 V 22A (Tc) 140W (Tc) Through Hole TO-220

quote
Alternative Part

N-Channel 650 V 22.4A (Tc) 195.3W (Tc) Through Hole PG-TO220-3

quote

Substitution Feasibility Conclusion

In most medium- and high-voltage switching power supply applications, the IPP65R150CFDAAKSA1 can serve as a replacement for the STP30N65M5. However, dynamic performance and thermal compatibility must be evaluated based on the specific application. Direct substitution is not recommended for designs that are extremely sensitive to conduction loss or switching frequency.

Comparison Points

1. On‑Resistance Test Conditions Differ - STP30N65M5: 139 mΩ @ 11 A; Infineon: 150 mΩ @ 9.3 A (both @ Vgs = 10 V) - ST’s measurement at higher current may give it an advantage in conduction loss at elevated temperatures. Full‑operating‑condition losses should be assessed in conjunction with the temperature coefficient. 2. Switching Performance & Drive Requirements - The STP30N65M5 has a significantly lower Qg (64 nC) than the Infineon part (86 nC), but its Ciss (2880 pF) is higher. - The Infineon device may exhibit lower Miller capacitance at the same Vgs, offering better noise immunity, though its higher Qg requires verification of drive current capability. The ST device is more suitable for high‑frequency switching, but attention must be paid to the impact of Ciss on drive speed. 3. Reliability & Temperature Range - Infineon is AEC‑Q101 qualified with an operating temperature range of –40 °C to 150 °C. ST does not specify automotive qualification, and the lower temperature limit is not clearly stated. - The Infineon part is suitable for automotive or high‑reliability industrial applications, offering better tolerance to cold‑start and temperature cycling. 4. Thermal & Package Design - Infineon’s rated power dissipation is 195.3 W (vs. ST’s 140 W), but actual thermal performance depends on package thermal resistance. The PG‑TO220‑3 package may feature optimized creepage distance or internal bonding. - Under equivalent cooling conditions, the Infineon device may allow higher output power, but PCB layout and insulation requirements must be verified for compatibility. 5. Technology Platform Differences - ST employs MDmesh™ V (a multi‑epitaxial super‑junction structure), while Infineon uses CoolMOS™ CFD7. - CoolMOS CFD7 is optimized for lower reverse recovery charge (Qrr) and improved avalanche ruggedness, which can reduce diode reverse‑recovery losses in hard‑switching topologies. MDmesh V emphasizes a balance between conduction loss and switching speed.
Analysis ID: 6916-A60D000
Based on part parameters and for reference only. Not to be used for procurement or production.
SkyChip © 2026, Email: sales@skychip.com