Original Part
Bipolar (BJT) Transistor NPN 40 V 1 A 150MHz 1 W Surface Mount SOT-89-3

Alternative Part
Bipolar (BJT) Transistor NPN 60 V 1 A 100MHz 2 W Surface Mount PG-SOT89

Substitution Feasibility Conclusion
In most general-purpose switching and low-to-medium frequency amplification applications, the BCX5516H6433XTMA1 can serve as a drop-in replacement for the FCX491ATA, offering advantages in both cost and reliability. However, in specific linear circuits that rely on high DC gain or operate at elevated frequencies, careful verification is recommended.
Comparison Points
1. DC Gain (hFE) and Test Conditions: The FCX491ATA specifies a minimum hFE of 300 @ 500mA, 5V, which is significantly higher than the BCX5516H6433XTMA1's rating of 100 @ 150mA, 2V. At the same high-current operating point (e.g., 500mA), the actual gain of the BCX5516 is likely to be lower. This may necessitate changes in drive requirements or lead to performance differences within the linear amplification region.
2. Power Dissipation Capability: The maximum power dissipation of the BCX5516 (2W) is double that of the FCX491ATA (1W). Under identical thermal conditions, the BCX5516 can handle greater power loss or permit a higher ambient operating temperature. This provides a larger design margin and superior thermal reliability.
3. Frequency Characteristics: The transition frequency (fT) of the FCX491ATA (150MHz) is higher than that of the BCX5516 (100MHz). In high-frequency switching or amplification applications (e.g., >50MHz), the FCX491ATA may offer better switching speed or high-frequency response.
4. Reliability Grade: The BCX5516 carries AEC-Q101 certification and is marked as an "Automotive" grade component, whereas the FCX491ATA is classified as commercial/industrial grade. The BCX5516 has undergone more stringent automotive electronic reliability testing, providing greater assurance against vibration, temperature cycling, and long-term reliability. This makes it particularly suitable for automotive or industrial environments with high-reliability requirements.
Analysis ID: 37DD-10BB000
Based on part parameters and for reference only. Not to be used for procurement or production.
SkyChip © 2026, Email: sales@skychip.com
