Original Part
Alternative Part
1. HCPL-817-30AE Substitution Conclusion
From a fundamental functionality and package perspective, the HCPL-817-30AE can serve as a substitute for the EL817(S1)(TA). Both are single-channel, 5kV isolated, transistor-output optocouplers with identical packages and key dynamic parameters (switching times). The primary differences are twofold.
First, the Current Transfer Ratio (CTR) range differs significantly. The HCPL-817-30AE has a narrower CTR range (80%-160%) compared to the original's broad range (50%-600%), with an overall lower gain. This indicates higher consistency in transfer efficiency but a smaller gain window. In circuits where the original design relies on high CTR (e.g., >160%) or has redundancy for very low CTR (<80%), there is a risk of insufficient drive, potentially necessitating recalibration of the input current.
Second, the output voltage capability is superior. The HCPL-817-30AE's 70V output withstand voltage is notably higher than the original's 35V, providing better safety margin and applicability on the high-voltage side—a clear advantage.
Therefore, the HCPL-817-30AE is a viable substitute, offering higher voltage reliability, provided the application's CTR requirement falls within the 80%-160% range and the input drive current is adjustable.
2. HCPL-817-30BE Substitution Conclusion
The HCPL-817-30BE is a direct drop-in replacement for the EL817(S1)(TA) in terms of package, isolation, and basic functionality, representing the higher-performance match among the three options. Its core deviations from the original also lie in CTR and output voltage.
The CTR range (130%-260%), while still narrower than the original's (50%-600%), has a significantly higher lower limit (130% vs. 50%). Its upper limit (260%) also covers the original's typical mid-to-high gain region. This enables the HCPL-817-30BE to deliver stronger and more stable signal transmission. However, it may be unsuitable for original circuits specifically designed to leverage very low CTR (e.g., using 50% for linear adjustment of weak signals), as its minimum gain is higher.
The output voltage capability is similarly enhanced to 70V, improving suitability in higher-voltage environments.
In summary, provided the target circuit does not depend on operation at very low CTR values, the HCPL-817-30BE is not only a reliable replacement but also offers higher transfer efficiency and output voltage margin.
Analysis ID: AE54-5DF2000
Based on part parameters and for reference only. Not to be used for procurement or production.
SkyChip © 2026, Email: sales@skychip.com

