Original Part
Alternative Part
1. HCPL-817-30AE Substitution Conclusion
The HCPL-817-30AE can serve as a substitute for the EL817(S)(TA), provided key parameter matching is verified, with the potential for performance improvements. Three primary differences exist:
First, the Current Transfer Ratio (CTR) ranges differ. The EL817 has a CTR of 50%-600%, while the HCPL-817-30AE is specified at 80%-160%. Substitution will result in a more stable operating point (e.g., output current) and better lot-to-lot consistency. However, the design must ensure reliable turn-on is maintained within this narrower CTR window, and the potentially very high CTR margin of the original part cannot be utilized.
Second, the output voltage withstand capability differs. The HCPL-817-30AE's maximum output voltage rating of 70V is significantly higher than the EL817's 35V, offering greater reliability and margin in higher-voltage load or switching applications.
Third, the maximum forward input current is slightly lower (50mA vs. 60mA). The drive requirement on the input side remains largely comparable to the original, though the absolute limit is reduced, which may require verification in extreme design conditions.
In summary, this substitution is feasible and offers superior voltage withstand performance, provided the application circuit's CTR requirement falls within the 80%-160% range.
2. HCPL-817-30BE Substitution Conclusion
The HCPL-817-30BE can substitute for the EL817(S)(TA) and offers key performance advantages, with CTR compatibility being the critical factor for successful replacement. The differences are similarly focused on three points:
First, the CTR range differs significantly. The HCPL-817-30BE's CTR of 130%-260% is substantially higher than the EL817's minimum of 50% and is more tightly specified. Substitution can yield greater output current drive capability for the same input current or allow for a smaller input current, aiding in power reduction and efficiency gains. However, it is essential to verify that the original design does not lead to excessive output saturation depth or degraded switching speed with this higher CTR.
Second, identical to the -30AE, its 70V output voltage rating is a major advantage over the original's 35V, enabling direct use in higher-voltage lines with improved reliability.
Finally, its maximum forward input current is also 50mA, the same as the -30AE.
If the application circuit can effectively utilize and accommodate the higher CTR value, this substitution not only achieves functional replacement but also enhances drive capability and voltage withstand rating.
Analysis ID: 7EAC-4A2B000
Based on part parameters and for reference only. Not to be used for procurement or production.
SkyChip © 2026, Email: sales@skychip.com