(HKG) +86 755 8277 4696
WhatsAppWhatsApp
English
SkyChip
0
Original Part

N-Channel 40 V 70A (Tc) 58W (Tc) Through Hole PG-TO220-3-1

quote
Alternative Part

N-Channel 40 V 53A (Ta), 100A (Tc) 115W (Tc) Through Hole TO-220-3

quote

Substitution Feasibility Conclusion

Substitution is possible under specific conditions, but thermal design, drive circuitry, and reliability requirements must be carefully evaluated. The two devices differ in key performance characteristics and suitable application areas.

Comparison Points

1. Current Rating and Test Basis Differ The IPP70N04S406AKSA1 is rated for 70A (Tc) based on case temperature, while the CSD18504KCS specifies 53A (Ta) / 100A (Tc). Under the same ambient temperature with reliance on natural convection (Ta), the CSD18504KCS may exhibit a lower continuous current capability. Its rated performance can only be achieved if the thermal design maintains the case temperature (Tc) close to the test condition. 2. Differences in On-Resistance and Switching Characteristics The IPP70N04S406AKSA1 has an Rds(on) of 6.5mΩ @70A, whereas the CSD18504KCS specifies 7mΩ @40A. The latter may experience a more pronounced increase in conduction loss at higher currents. Meanwhile, the CSD18504KCS features a lower Qg (25nC vs. 32nC) and a lower Vgs(th) (2.3V vs. 4V), indicating faster switching speed and a lower drive threshold, but also imposing higher noise immunity requirements on the gate drive circuit. 3. Thermal Design and Power Dissipation Limits The CSD18504KCS is rated for a Pd of 115W (Tc), significantly higher than the 58W (Tc) of the IPP70N04S406AKSA1, but its maximum junction temperature is lower (150°C vs. 175°C). The former requires more robust cooling to realize its power handling advantage and may be more limited in high-temperature environments. 4. Reliability Standards and Application Fields The IPP70N04S406AKSA1 is AEC-Q101 qualified and automotive-grade, making it suitable for high-reliability applications such as automotive electronics. The CSD18504KCS lacks such certification and is oriented more toward industrial or general-purpose use. Additional validation may be necessary under stress conditions like vibration and temperature cycling. 5. Drive Voltage Range Optimization The CSD18504KCS specifies two drive voltages (4.5V/10V), indicating it can achieve low Rds(on) even at a lower gate voltage, making it suitable for low-voltage drive systems. In contrast, the IPP70N04S406AKSA1 requires 10V drive to reach its optimal conduction performance.
Analysis ID: E3DE-5912000
Based on part parameters and for reference only. Not to be used for procurement or production.
SkyChip © 2026, Email: sales@skychip.com