(HKG) +86 755 8277 4696
WhatsAppWhatsApp
English
SkyChip
0
Original Part

SDRAM - DDR Memory IC 128Mbit Parallel 200 MHz 700 ps 66-TSOP II

Quote
Alternative Part

SDRAM - DDR Memory IC 128Mbit SSTL_2 200 MHz 50 ns 66-TSOP II

Quote

SDRAM - DDR Memory IC 128Mbit SSTL_2 200 MHz 50 ns 66-TSOP II

Quote
1. W9412G6KH-5I Substitution Conclusion From a core parameter perspective, the W9412G6KH-5I is identical to the original part in memory density (128Mbit), organization (8M x 16), operating voltage (2.3V~2.7V), package (66-TSSOP), and clock frequency (200MHz), establishing a foundation for direct hardware compatibility. Two key discrepancies exist. First, the interface standard: the original part is listed as "Parallel," while the Winbond part explicitly specifies "SSTL_2"—a standard electrical interface for DDR SDRAM. In practice, this likely only requires verification of motherboard driver compatibility. Second, and more critical, is the Access Time. The original part specifies 700ps (0.7ns), whereas the Winbond part lists 50ns. For DDR SDRAM, "Access Time" typically refers to the clock-to-data-out delay (tAC). The original part's 0.7ns aligns with typical tAC for DDR-400 (200MHz clock). The 50ns value likely corresponds to a different timing parameter, such as tRCD or tRAS, indicating a potential mislabeling or descriptive variance in the datasheet. If the 50ns indeed represents a parameter like tRCD/tRAS, it could represent a significant deviation from the original part's typical range (15-20ns), potentially leading to system timing mismatches or performance degradation. It is strongly recommended to verify timing compatibility through bench testing prior to substitution and to confirm the motherboard memory controller can accommodate the Winbond part's timing requirements.
2. W9412G6KH-5 Substitution Conclusion The parameter description for the W9412G6KH-5 is identical to that of the W9412G6KH-5I. Therefore, the substitution conclusion is the same: hardware package and basic electrical characteristics are compatible, but the interface standard (SSTL_2) and the listed Access Time (50ns) remain critical points of divergence. Note that the suffix difference ("-5" vs. "-5I") may indicate a temperature grade or revision variant (e.g., "I" often denotes an industrial temperature range), though this distinction is not reflected in the provided parameter table. If the original application has specific temperature requirements, the full Winbond datasheet must be consulted to ensure coverage matches the original part's operating temperature range. In summary, both Winbond parts are physically compatible candidates. However, thorough validation of timing parameters against system requirements is mandatory. The significant disparity between the 50ns listed access time and the original 700ps likely points to a different timing part. Functional and stability verification through actual circuit testing is essential before implementation.
Analysis ID: 5C39-9687000
Based on part parameters and for reference only. Not to be used for procurement or production.
SkyChip © 2026, Email: sales@skychip.com