Original Part
SDRAM - DDR Memory IC 128Mbit Parallel 200 MHz 700 ps 66-TSOP II

Alternative Part
1. W9412G6KH-5I Substitution Conclusion
From a core functionality and specification standpoint, the W9412G6KH-5I can serve as a direct replacement for the AS4C8M16D1A-5TINTR, as their key parameters are highly aligned: both are 128Mbit (8Mx16) DDR SDRAM devices, utilize the same 66-TSSOP package, and share identical operating voltage (2.3V-2.7V) and clock frequency (200MHz). The differences lie in the interface standard and access time parameter. The original part lists its interface as "Parallel," whereas the W9412G6KH-5I explicitly specifies "SSTL_2." This is essentially two descriptions for the same physical interface; SSTL_2 is the standard parallel interface electrical specification for DDR SDRAM. The two are electrically compatible, but it is necessary to verify that the motherboard termination resistor design, among other factors, meets SSTL_2 requirements. The other discrepancy is in access time: the original part specifies 700ps (likely referring to a specific parameter like tAC), while the Winbond part specifies 50ns (typically referring to tRCD or tAC). This numerical difference is significant but is most likely due to differing annotation methods or measurement conditions between data sources. Given that both share the same 200MHz clock (5ns cycle), a 50ns access time is consistent with typical DDR-200 specifications. The 700ps notation should be cross-referenced with the original manufacturer's full datasheet to confirm its exact meaning. In the vast majority of DDR-200 system designs, the Winbond part's timing parameters are acceptable. Provided that the PCB design supports SSTL_2 signaling levels and the system has sufficient timing margin, this part can proceed to substitution verification.
2. W9412G6KH-5 Substitution Conclusion
The W9412G6KH-5 is identical to the W9412G6KH-5I in all provided parameters; therefore, its substitution conclusion is fundamentally the same. It is also a viable replacement candidate for the AS4C8M16D1A-5TINTR. The core differences between these parts and the original—namely, the explicit SSTL_2 interface standard and the access time (50ns) parameter—apply here as well. The key distinction between the "-5" and "-5I" suffixes typically relates to operating temperature range (not explicitly stated here, but "I" often denotes Industrial grade), while the "IN" in the original part's "-5TINTR" suffix also typically indicates an Industrial temperature range. Consequently, if the original design requires an Industrial temperature range (e.g., -40°C to +85°C), the W9412G6KH-5I with the "I" suffix should be prioritized to ensure reliability. If the application operates within a Commercial temperature range (0°C to +70°C), the W9412G6KH-5 may be more cost-effective. Beyond this temperature consideration, the interface and timing factors affecting substitution feasibility for both parts align with the conclusion stated above.
Analysis ID: 0D17-AE0B000
Based on part parameters and for reference only. Not to be used for procurement or production.
SkyChip © 2026, Email: sales@skychip.com


