Alternative Part
1. LM248DT Substitution Conclusion
The LM248DT demonstrates low feasibility as a replacement, primarily due to a fundamental mismatch in supply voltage range. The LM248DT is specified for a single supply of 44V (both minimum and maximum ratings indicate a fixed high-voltage design), whereas the original MC33174D supports a wide 3V to 44V range. Consequently, the LM248DT is incompatible with low-voltage or wide-supply applications. Furthermore, its quiescent current (2.1 mA per channel) is significantly higher than the original's 180 µA per channel, leading to substantially increased power dissipation. Key dynamic parameters are also degraded: slew rate (0.5 V/µs) and gain-bandwidth product (1.3 MHz) are lower than the original's 2.1 V/µs and 2.1 MHz, respectively. Although the input offset voltage (1 mV) is slightly better, the overall performance is markedly inferior. The LM248DT is only suitable for fixed high-voltage applications where power consumption and speed are not critical, and it cannot directly replicate the original part's wide-voltage, low-power characteristics.
2. AD8684ARZ Substitution Conclusion
The AD8684ARZ offers partial feasibility as a substitute, but system requirements must be rigorously evaluated. Its key advantages stem from the JFET input stage, providing ultra-low input bias current (6 pA vs. 20 nA) and superior input offset voltage (350 µV vs. 2 mV). This makes it well-suited for high-impedance sensing and precision measurement applications. Additionally, its dynamic performance is better, with higher slew rate (9 V/µs) and gain-bandwidth product (3.5 MHz) than the original part. However, its supply range (9V to 36V) is narrower than the original's 3V to 44V, excluding it from low-voltage or >36V applications. Its output current capability (12 mA) is only 44% of the original's 27 mA, which may limit performance when driving capacitive or low-impedance loads. If the system operates within 9V–36V and does not require high output current, the AD8684ARZ can be considered a high-performance alternative. Care should be taken to account for inherent differences between JFET and standard BJT amplifiers in parameters such as noise and temperature drift.
Analysis ID: 52A5-ACBC000
Based on part parameters and for reference only. Not to be used for procurement or production.
SkyChip © 2026, Email: sales@skychip.com